Haha oh my goodness, the list would be absolutely gigantic.  I once counted them all up and it was 40 or 50.  But here are a few of the main ones I can remember at the moment:

Dominic Deegan: Oracle for Hire
MSPaintAdventures (back in the Problem Sleuth days, I swear!)
Gunnerkrigg Court
Sam and Fuzzy
Three Panel Soul / Mac Hall
Nedroid
Wilde Life
Order of the Stick
Head Trip
Awkward Zombie
Brawl in the Family
Manly Guys Doing Manly Things (The Punchline is Machismo)
Slightly Damned
Not a Villain
Questionable Content
Kiwi Blitz
Dinosaur Comics
XKCD
Finished comics like Comedity and Finders Keepers (Garth Graham's comics before Star Power)
Old mainstays like vgcats
That Snafu Powerpuff girls one
F@nb0y$ way back when it was incredibly awesome
Slackerz

gosh there's like so many and so many of them are gone now...

toooo many

Demon Street
Cucumber Quest
Monsterkind
Beyond the Canopy
Wilde Life
Gunnerkrigg Court
Skullkickers
Vibe
Kiwi Blitz
xkcd
Whomp
Dumbing of Age
Necropolis
Godslave
Lets Speak English
Otaku Dad
No Need for Bushido
Manly Guys Doing Manly Things
balderdash!
Modest Medusa
Ava's Demon
MercWorks
Back
All Night

Oh yeah, your list reminds me, I read Mary Cagle's Let's Speak English as well, along with Ava's Demon, and Dumbing of Age through the Comic Chameleon iPhone app. Cucumber Quest has always been one I've wanted to get into, but I just haven't yet...

So far, I've gotten into

Cucumber Quest

Awaken

Clockwork

The Artist and the Machine

Homestuck

Vibe

And there are others I've started, but then I forgot about them since I hadn't gone in too deep yet.

But seriously if you haven't read Cucumber Quest it's one of the best webcomics out there.

I'm hoping this thread hasn't completely died...

But I read a whole bunch of webcomics. There's:
Homestuck
Lackadaisy
Hotblood
Witchy
Stand Still, Stay Silent
Namesake
Ava's Demon
Monsterkind
Balderdash
Hemlock
Agents of the Realm
Sister Claire
Famib
Property of Hate
The Last Halloween
Run Freak Run
Family Man
The World in Deeper Inspection
Widdershins
Demon Street

... Wow. That's a lot. There's a few more I check in with occasionally.

There's also my own. Although, I don't know if you could really say I read that...?
It's called Potboiler Carp, I can't link you to it since I'm new here. But it's just potboilercarp dot tumblr dot com. It's about sphinxes and the collective knowledge of the universe, if anyone feels like giving that a read.

Paranatural is the only webcomic I keep up with nowadays.

But I did read Nimona while it was still in-progress and on the website. Good stuff!

Oooh, other webcomics!

I'll take on the challenge from years ago: Who has the biggest list?

All of the webcomics which I have bookmarked:

Let's Speak English!
Stand Still Stay Silent (blood)
Will Save World For Gold (pixelated, blood)
Quantum Vibe
Go Get A Roomie! (NSFW)
Dumbing of Age
Sandra and Woo
Ava's Demon (Hasn't updated in a while... Also, gore)
Wilde Life (blood)
Looking For Group (blood, gore)
Whomp!
Two Guys and Guy (blood)
Girl Genius!
Monster Pulse
Awaken
Hero Oh Hero (blood)
Unsounded (Gore)
Gunnerkrigg Court
The Lonely Vincent Bellingham
Lighter Than Heir (blood)
Guilded Age (Gore)
Never Satisfied
Namesake
Blindsprings
Trying Human (aliens)
Not Drunk Enough (blood, for sure)
Daughter of the Lillies (some gore)
The Creators
Monsterkind
Spinnerette
Gaia
Alice and the Nightmare (relatively new)
The Boy Who Fell (Gore. Lots of blood)
White Noise
Not a Villain
Supernormal Step
The End
The Cat and the Fiddle
Widdershins
Goblins (Gore)
SAKANA
Bluechair
164 Days
Carciphona (Gore)
Earthsong (Gore)
Rumplestiltskin
Witchy
Miamaska
Fey Winds
Solstoria
The Gamer
Hooky
Scandinavia and the World
Peritale
Helvetica
Dia
The GaMER CaT
Riven Seal
Jikoshia
The Black Brick Road of Oz
Undead Ed
Idlestatus
Order of the Stick
Erfworld
Todd Allison and the Petunia Violet
Harpy Gee
Beyond the Canopy
Prequel (occasionally NSFW)
Zoophobia
Stick In The Mud (NSFW at times)
Grrl Power
Frivolesque
A Better Place (new)
Lines (new)
Boxer Hockey (Not updating)

And, of course, our beloved Paranatural. <3

There's a theme here.

The theme is action, violence, and supernatural/fantasy/etc OR slice of life. Sometimes both.

I WONDER WHAT KIND OF COMICS I ENJOY?
;P

List count: 76 comics

...I have too much time on my hands.

Let's see.

SIGNS (on indefinite hiatus)
Ava's Demon (on hiatus)
Demon's Mirror (completed, but I'm in the process of reading it)
Awkward Zombie
A Better Place (by the same author as Demon's Mirror, currently updating)

I've read Demon's Mirror, it's really good! Not as good as Paranatural thoooooooooooooooough!~ *runs away*

I actually don't read many webcomics, they have never really been my thing. I have only read 2 webcomics ever, those being Pnat and Homestuck. Of those, Pnat is the only one I've actually enjoyed.

Just from skimming through this thread, it seems like I could spend the rest of my natural born life doing nothing but reading webcomics.

That's probably true. Same thing goes for watching anime.

I read:

Paranatural
Vibe
Homestuck
Monsterkind (surprised how few mentions it's been getting)
Beyond the Canopy
and...maybe NEOKOSMOS.

Oooh! Monster kind and Beyond the Canopy are both really good comics! I kinda wish we would get back to Vega and... Uh... What was his name again? This is terrible! It's been so long that I forgot his name! I must immediately remedy this! *rereads BtC*

Helvetica
Homestuck
Oglaf
Paranatural

There are several more I'd like to read but have not gotten around to yet.

I read a lot of webcomics (a lottttttttt) and wasn't really planning on posting here, but since I see many people read some of the same stuff as me I decided I might as well.

Homestuck
Vibe
Cucumber Quest
Beyond the canopy
Monsterkind
El goonish shive
Gunnerkrigg court
Ava's demon
Demon's mirror
A better place
Awkward zombie
Two Guys and Guy
Unsounded
Guilded Age
Blindspring
Daughter of the Lillies
Supernormal Step
Widdershins
Earthsong
Fey Winds
Scandinavia and the World
Order of the Stick
Prequel
Sorcery101
Skindeep
Flaky Pastry
True magic
Slightly damned
Manly guys doing manly things
Lackadaisy
Archipelago
Mokepon
Power nap
Star power
The glass scientists
No need for bushido

And a bunch of other ones that I don't feel like typing out because damn... There's also a bunch of finished comics I've read and some I started reading and still have bookmarked but waiting to read again when there's a bit more progress...

Oh, that reminds me!
Has anyone here ever made it through the entirety of Terror Island before?
It's a goddamned hilarious photocomic and a must read.

Haven't heard of that before...

This is the first page.
It ended some years ago, and the creators are now working on other things.

O.O

I've read/I'm reading at least 17 of those comics, Apophyllite! I guess we share similar tastes, huh?

Since it seems you're probably already reading most webcomics that exist, there's bound to be some overlap XD

But yeah, a big chunk of those I didn't even have to type out myself, just copy pasted them from your list... Which was helpfull because otherwise I'd have probably given up after 5 >_>
There's also a few more on your list that I've started reading but am not keeping up with. They're just hanging out in my bookmarks untill I feel like reading them from the start again. Like Girl Genius, The End, Trying Human, Jikoshia, Looking for Group, Helvetica, Gaia.
I started reading Spinnerette once but sorta gave up on it...

(ﾉ◕ヮ◕)ﾉ*:･ﾟ✧ even more overlap! Sorta, maybe...

Glad to be of help! Though, I'm probably not reading even close to a hundredth of the comics that exist. Not even a thousandth, I'd say.

Trying Human is cool, though the update schedule is a little sporadic at the moment, so I guess it would be better for some people to wait a while longer before reading it, especially since they're remaking the first chapters of the comic so that the art looks better.

Girl Genius was awesome, all the way up until the end of the first part, but now it's not quite as interesting, and is a little bit boring. The Jeagers are awesome characters, and there is a distinct lack of them at the moment. I'm gonna keep reading though, since even if it's slowed down a little bit the story is pretty cool and I wanna see where it goes.

The End, Looking for Group, Spinnerette, and Gaia are pretty good comics too, though I don't like them as much as Pnat or Order of the Stick or Beyond the Canopy. I read Spinnerette for a while, then dropped it, then picked it up again, though it's not like that for any of the other comics I'm talking about in this section except for The End. Looking for Group has a cool premise and pretty interesting story, but I'm having a hard time liking the main character for some reason... I don't really know why. Gaia is also pretty interesting, though it's a little... slow? for me, or something. I'm not quite sure, but there's just something about it that doesn't quite catch my attention as much as it could. The End is also a little tedious at times, I think.

I like Jikoshia, but they aren't updating very often, which is a shame, so it would probably be best to wait a while before starting that one again. Same for Helvetica, though that one is updating more often than Jikoshia, I think, if just barely.

Totally counts as overlap, by the way.

(Wonder where that sudden comic rating thing came from. *shrug*)

I agree with basically all of that... Some stories are great and totally capture your attention so you can't stop reading, but slow updates can make it hard to keep up with those stories sometimes... Just leaving them bookmarked to get back to later is kinda my way of dealing with that.

Did that for Paranatural for a few months but when I read it again when it was much further, I just got totally hooked ;_; Still sorta painfull how slow it goes sometimes, but each page being totally hilarious even if not much plot is going on really helps keep me checking back every week instead of just benching it with the others...

And then there's the ones that're kinda interesting and great to check up on when you're bored but they're kinda meh most of the times so you don't really get the urge to keep up with the updates...

Yep! But I keep up with updates anyway because if I don't I'll probably forget about them or something. Plus it's a way to waste some time.

I just have a bookmark list with every comic I'm reading along with every comic I've started reading and am going back to eventually, maybe. So everytime I go to check up on the comics I'm keeping up with, I also have to scroll past a bunch of comics I'm currently not reading. If I ever get bored enough and have some time, I can just start reading one of those...

The way I have it organized is by update schedule. I have an infrequent/unknown folder, though I check those comics pretty often despite their rare updates...

Like I said, wasting time